I conducted an analysis of 2026 punditry. The pundits didn’t do so well.

Like most people, I was shocked by the size of Democrats’ Election Day victory, a 14-point margin in the popular vote, only overtaken by the 1974 mid-term repudiating Richard Nixon’s Republican Party. While my resume includes political consultant and political reporter, I no longer pour over voter data or spend hours on the phone with candidates and other consultants like I once used to. I’m just not as informed anymore, so I don’t have the tools to see around political corners.

But there are people who claim they do: Political pundits! 

Over the last twenty years, the rise of email newsletters and podcasts has enabled an industry of political pundits to expound on what’s right and wrong, and to tell us the likely outcome of this or that political action. I find these pundits simultaneously annoying and interesting. 

Annoying because: How do you know? When I was tightly plugged into the political machine as a consultant and then a reporter, I sometimes gained confidence of an outcome, but was mostly wary of what’s to come. I was always unsure when various political people told me “X will happen because of Y”. 

Interesting because: What is your political experience worth if you can’t see the political future? I would – and still do – absorb pundit and consultant analysis in an effort to soothsay the future. If I can find that one little nugget, I tell myself, then I’ll really know what’s to come.

So, blessed with the tools of AI, I decided to test that all out.

With the assistance of Claude, back in April I built a system to pull in over 100 left, center, and right-wing political newsletters and podcasts, and launched it as newsletterzeitgeist.site. Every day it runs a summary of the day’s punditry and keeps transcripts of everything collected. Using that database, I set AI on an analysis task of over a million words between September 1 and November 14. I asked two questions:

  • Who, if anyone, saw the blue wave coming?
  • Did pundits notice major turning points in the 2026 election?

My conclusion to the first is: They saw a Democratic victory, but until the last week before Election Day, almost nobody saw a “wave”, and even that was widely disputed. And to the second, few pundits actually understood the turning points they were in – with the exception of centrists sometimes.

I’ve published detailed reports here with lots of fun charts and graphs: 

2026 Analysis Overview

Based on this analysis, I don’t think pundits really see much more into the future than anyone who reads news reports closely. While there may be certain pundits who do the work better than others, as a class, I think this report tells us that punditry is actually like sports radio but for politics. It’s better thought of as entertainment, rather than providing actual insight.

From now on, I think I’m going to reduce my pundit diet.

← Back to Home